A visit to Niantic, CT, isn’t complete without indulging in its vibrant food scene. Known for its seaside charm, rich history, and welcoming community, this coastal village offers an array of eateries that cater to every palate. Whether craving fresh seafood, comforting classics, or something with an international twist, Niantic has it all.
If you’re a tourist wondering where to eat, this guide is here to help. From hidden gems to popular hotspots, we’ve curated a list of the best Restaurants in Niantic CT, that you won’t want to miss. Get ready to discover the ultimate tourist dining guide for Niantic, CT and make your visit all the more memorable.
Why Niantic is a Food Lover’s Paradise
Before we dig into specific restaurants, it’s worth noting why Niantic stands out as a foodie destination. Situated on the Long Island Sound, its location gives it access to some of the freshest seafood in the region. The town’s culture is also a blend of New England traditions and contemporary innovation, reflected in its diverse dining options. Whether you’re after a gourmet experience or looking for local eats in Niantic, CT, there’s something for every craving.
1. The Black Sheep
If you’re looking for a warm and welcoming pub vibe, The Black Sheep is a must-visit. This cozy Irish pub offers a menu brimming with hearty dishes like shepherd’s pie, Guinness-braised short ribs, and fresh fish and chips. Pair your meal with one of their many local craft beers for the ultimate experience. The Black Sheep is a favorite among locals and tourists alike, making it a top contender among the best Niantic, CT restaurants.
Insider Tip
Their outdoor patio is perfect for sunny afternoons, and they host live music on select weekends. It’s the ideal spot for a laid-back evening in town.
2. Skipper’s Seafood
A trip to Niantic without fresh seafood is like visiting Paris without tasting a croissant. Enter Skipper’s Seafood—a local institution. From golden-fried clam strips to buttery lobster rolls, this casual seafood shack has been serving mouthwatering classics for decades.
Must-Try
Order the famous lobster roll, packed with chunks of tender lobster and served on a perfectly toasted bun. For dessert, grab some soft-serve ice cream to enjoy by the water.
3. Lillian’s Cafe
For a touch of sophistication, head over to Lillian’s Cafe. This quaint yet elegant spot is known for its refined menu and charming atmosphere. Lillian’s specializes in dishes that use locally sourced ingredients, ensuring peak freshness and flavor.
Featured Dish
Try their pan-seared scallops or the duck confit. Pair it with a glass of wine from their thoughtfully curated selection for a truly memorable meal.
4. Niantic Public House & Brewery
Beer enthusiasts, rejoice! Niantic Public House & Brewery is your go-to for locally brewed craft beer and a relaxed vibe. While it’s technically a brewery, they frequently feature food trucks on-site to complete your dining experience.
Best Pairing
Grab a pint of their popular Sound Waves IPA and pair it with tacos or wood-fired pizza from the visiting food truck of the day.
5. Charlie’s Place
Looking for a classic New England diner experience? Charlie’s Place is a favorite among locals for breakfast, brunch, and beyond. Known for its generous portions and homey vibe, this spot will transport you back to simpler times.
Breakfast Highlight
Treat yourself to their signature crab cake eggs benedict or raspberry-filled pancakes. It’s the perfect start to a day of exploring Niantic.
6. East Coast Taco
Sometimes, you just need a hearty taco fix—and that’s where East Coast Taco comes in. This no-fuss eatery delivers big flavors with fresh ingredients and creative fillings. The laid-back atmosphere makes it a great pick for families or solo travelers.
Taco Alert
Don’t miss their shrimp tacos, loaded with fresh shrimp, zesty lime, and a tangy taco sauce.
7. La Llorona Progressive Mexican Cuisine
For an upscale twist on traditional Mexican dishes, La Llorona is a standout. The dishes here are modern, sophisticated, and packed with bold flavors. Authenticity meets creativity at this one-of-a-kind spot.
Chef’s Recommendation
The mole enchiladas are a standout, with rich, complex spices that will leave your taste buds in awe.
8. Main Street Grille
Looking for a place to catch the game or enjoy a casual meal with friends? Main Street Grille has you covered. This family-friendly eatery features an extensive menu with something for everyone, from juicy burgers to healthy salads.
Local Favorite
Their seafood chowder consistently earns rave reviews and perfectly complements a crisp New England evening.
9. Dev’s on Main
One of Niantic’s hidden gems, Dev’s on Main is a cozy restaurant offering a menu of eclectic small plates. Perfect for a relaxed evening of sharing dishes, this spot delivers bold flavors and a relaxed yet chic atmosphere.
Don’t Skip
The lobster mac and cheese is indulgence at its finest. Pair it with one of their handcrafted cocktails for the ultimate treat.
10. The Book Barn Café
Last but not least, for a truly unique dining experience, swing by The Book Barn Café. Nestled within Niantic’s famous secondhand bookstore, this café offers delightful baked goods, artisanal bread, and delicious coffee. Grab a snack, explore the treasure trove of books, and soak in the cozy ambience.
Sweet Treat
Try one of their fresh pastries with a creamy latte—it’s simple but oh-so-satisfying.
Which Niantic Restaurant Will You Try First?
Niantic’s dining scene reflects the town itself—vibrant, charming, and unpretentiously inviting. The options are endless, from seafood shacks to fine dining establishments, but every bite offers a taste of what makes this coastal gem so special.
Whether you’re here for a day trip or an extended stay, make sure to check out at least a few of these amazing eateries. And if you’re feeling adventurous, why not try them all?
Want more recommendations for local eats in Niantic, CT or the best Niantic, CT restaurants? Comment below or share your favorite spot—we’d love to hear from you!