Busted news websites like “bustednewspaper.com” and similar platforms have become increasingly prevalent online. These sites primarily aggregate mugshots and arrest records, often obtained from public records, and display them for public consumption. They are designed to offer “crime news” while generating revenue through ads or removal fees. For those encountering these sites, whether as the subject of an unfair listing, a legal professional, or a privacy advocate, navigating their implications can be an intricate challenge. This guide will explore what these sites do, their criticisms, legal considerations, and how to address a mugshot listing responsibly.
Table of Contents
What Are “Busted News” Websites?
“Busted news” websites are online platforms that collect mugshots and arrest records from public databases and display them in one easily accessible location. They aim to share information about recent arrests by state, city, or county. Targeting public curiosity about crime, these websites monetize their content through on-page advertisements or charging fees to remove mugshots. Examples of such sites include “Busted Newspaper” and other similar aggregators.
While they rely primarily on public records for their content, their practices raise heated debates about ethics, accuracy, and predatory business models.
Criticisms of Busted News Websites
Despite their stated purpose of transparency, busted news websites have attracted significant criticism. Here are the most common complaints:
1. Predatory Business Practices
Many critics consider these websites predatory because they profit from the reputational harm individuals face when their mugshots are published. Some platforms charge hefty fees to remove listings, exploiting those desperate to recover their online reputation.
2. Difficulty Removing Mugshots
Mugshots can remain online even after cases are expunged, sealed, or dismissed. Victims report that getting their mugshots removed is often challenging, with no clear guidelines—and sometimes exorbitant costs—for initiating removal. Many of these websites will repost the image if it re-enters public data systems or if a similar aggregator duplicates it.
3. Potential for Misleading or Outdated Information
Busted news websites rely on public records, which may sometimes be incomplete or outdated. Users have reported inaccuracies, such as dismissed charges without updates to their details online. Misleading information can have long-term consequences for the individuals involved.
4. Privacy Violations
Though mugshots are public records under many jurisdictions, publishing them in a searchable and monetized format for global audiences brings ethical concerns about privacy and dignity, especially for individuals never convicted of crimes.
5. Limited Functionality
From issues such as apps not loading certain counties to bugs that make searching by state or full name impossible, the functionality of these websites often leaves much to be desired. This reflects a lack of investment in ensuring usability, further frustrating users.
Real-World Impacts on Individuals
The personal stories of those affected by these websites paint a grim picture. Many people report difficulties finding housing or employment because potential landlords or employers discovered their mugshots online, often making no distinction between charges and convictions.
For instance, one individual shared that their difficulty after the dismissal of their case wasn’t reflected on these websites, leaving a mugshot of them easily accessible online for friends, family, and colleagues to see. Such incidents worsen the stigma around arrests, even when no formal charges or convictions occur.
These websites’ practices harm individuals and highlight gaps in the legal and technological systems regulating such content.
Legal and Ethical Considerations
1. Is It Legal to Publish Mugshots Online?
Yes, in most jurisdictions, mugshots are considered public records and legally accessible. However, the for-profit nature of busted news websites raises legal and ethical concerns.
Some states, like California, have developed laws to prevent websites from charging fees for mugshot removal, aiming to reduce predatory practices. However, enforcement often lags, and many websites operate loopholes by hosting their businesses internationally.
2. The Ethical Debate
Even when legal, the ethics of hosting mugshots online remains a gray area. Critics argue:
- The practice assumes guilt before due process.
- It constitutes a “digital scarlet letter,” haunting subjects long after legal redemption.
- It disproportionately impacts marginalized groups, whose mugshots may flood these sites at higher rates.
How to Remove Mugshots from Busted News Websites
1. Contact the Website
Many of these sites require you to submit a removal request form or email them directly. However, be prepared for potential fees.
2. Seek Legal Assistance
If the mugshot relates to a dismissed or sealed case, you may have legal grounds to demand removal. States with anti-mugshot extortion laws can bolster your case. Consult a lawyer who is well-versed in defamation or privacy law for advice.
3. Leverage Reputation Management Services
Several online reputation management companies specialize in burying negative search results about individuals. However, these services often come with considerable costs.
4. Submit DMCA Takedown Notices
If you own the copyright of any images used on the website (e.g., personal photos), you may have grounds under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) to request their removal. This approach doesn’t work for mugshots, as they are public records, but it may address other instances where your likeness is used.
5. Optimize Your Online Presence
Publishing positive, accurate information about yourself can help push mugshots further down in search engine results. From creating professional profiles to starting a personal blog, reputation recovery often begins with content creation.
Alternatives to “Busted News” Websites
If you’re seeking crime-related public records without the moral baggage of mugshot websites, consider these alternatives:
- Official Government Websites
Local sheriff’s departments or court systems often host arrest records, providing more accurate (and often context-specific) data than busted news platforms.
- FOIA Requests
The Freedom of Information Act allows you to request access to records directly from relevant government agencies.
- Community News Publications
Traditional news outlets tend to follow stricter journalistic standards when reporting crime stories, reducing the likelihood of sensationalized and incomplete reporting.
FAQs About “Busted News” Websites
1. Where do Busted News websites get their information?
They typically obtain arrest records and mugshots from publicly available government databases.
2. Can I have outdated mugshots removed?
It depends on the website and local regulations. While some websites allow removal following legal proceedings, others may resist or demand payment.
3. Are these websites ethical?
While legally permissible, many argue they lack ethical grounding due to their exploitative and inaccurate practices that harm individuals’ reputations.
4. Do any states outlaw mugshot exploitation?
Yes, states like California and Georgia have laws prohibiting websites from charging for mugshot removal, but enforcement remains inconsistent.
5. Can I sue a busted news website?
If false information damages your reputation, legal action could be possible. Consult a privacy or defamation attorney for guidance.
A Thoughtful Approach to Busted News Websites
While transparency is necessary for public safety and accountability, busted news websites demonstrate how public information can be manipulated for profit at significant human cost. Protecting privacy, holding these sites accountable, and spreading awareness are the first steps toward a more ethical approach to public records.
If you’re navigating the challenges of mugshot listings or advocating for online accountability, bookmark and share this guide—it could make all the difference in protecting someone else’s reputation.
